Neuroimaging and Inferential Distance
نویسنده
چکیده
Brain images are used both as scientific evidence and to illustrate the results of neuroimaging experiments. These images are apt to be viewed as photographs of brain activity, and in so viewing them people are prone to assume that they share the evidential characteristics of photographs. Photographs are epistemically compelling, and have a number of characteristics that underlie what I call their inferential proximity. Here I explore the aptness of the photography analogy, and argue that although neuroimaging does bear important similarities to photography, the details of the generation and analysis of neuroimages significantly complicate the relation of the image to the data. Neuroimages are not inferentially proximate, but their seeming so increases the potential for misinterpretation. This suggests caution in appealing to such images in the public domain.
منابع مشابه
Functional Neuroimaging Can Support Causal Claims about Brain Function
Cognitive neuroscientists habitually deny that functional neuroimaging can furnish causal information about the relationship between brain events and behavior. However, imaging studies do provide causal information about those relationships-although not causal certainty. Although popular portrayals of functional neuroimaging tend to attribute too much inferential power to the technique, we shou...
متن کاملHemispheric specialization for communicative processing: neuroimaging data on the role of the right hemisphere
Neuropsychology has traditionally studied language emphasizing the exclusive control of the left hemisphere of the brain over this process. With the growing development of this area in psychology and the availability of neuroimaging techniques, a critical analysis of the traditional concept of cerebral dominance for language and of the bases of the neurobiological representations of this cognit...
متن کاملCross-validation and hypothesis testing in neuroimaging: An irenic comment on the exchange between Friston and Lindquist et al
The "ten ironic rules for statistical reviewers" presented by Friston (2012) prompted a rebuttal by Lindquist et al. (2013), which was followed by a rejoinder by Friston (2013). A key issue left unresolved in this discussion is the use of cross-validation to test the significance of predictive analyses. This note discusses the role that cross-validation-based and related hypothesis tests have c...
متن کاملPattern-based classification in functional neuroimaging 1 Running head: PATTERN-CLASSIFICATION IN FUNCTIONAL NEUROIMAGING Theoretical, statistical, and practical perspectives on pattern-based classification approaches to the analysis of functional neuroimaging data
The goal of pattern-based classification of functional neuroimaging data is to link individual brain activation patterns to the experimental conditions experienced during the scans. These " brain-reading " analyses advance functional neuroimaging on three fronts. From a technical standpoint, pattern-based classifiers overcome fatal flaws in the status quo inferential and exploratory multivariat...
متن کاملTheoretical, Statistical, and Practical Perspectives on Pattern-based Classification Approaches to the Analysis of Functional Neuroimaging Data
The goal of pattern-based classification of functional neuroimaging data is to link individual brain activation patterns to the experimental conditions experienced during the scans. These "brain-reading" analyses advance functional neuroimaging on three fronts. From a technical standpoint, pattern-based classifiers overcome fatal f laws in the status quo inferential and exploratory multivariate...
متن کامل